As numerous health systems halt gender-affirming care amid a crackdown from the current federal leadership, researchers and supporters warn that the science of sex and gender is being misrepresented – with major repercussions for healthcare for all Americans.
Expert Knowledge Being Challenged
Federal officials “lack a genuine grasp of the research at all,” said one expert, founder of Beyond X&Y and a PhD holder in genetic science. McCreight added that using misinformation to restrict medical care is a dangerous precedent for all patients.
“This pushback are fundamentally coming from a wider effort to undermine science and expertise and truth,” they said.
Another scientist, an assistant professor of biology at the a major university, said: “These oversimplified understandings of the science of biological sex are being used to justify transgender legislation and government rules.”
McLaughlin explained: “The science is being misrepresented in such a way to hurt people.”
New Federal Rules Restrict Care
The US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is finalizing a new rule that would prohibit Medicaid and Medicare payments for gender-affirming care to patients under 18, including medications like puberty blockers and hormones. The public comment period for this rule recently concluded. The HHS would also prevent government plans from paying for this care.
Consequently, major clinics – including institutions in New York, Washington, and Utah – report they have ended their youth gender-affirming care programs, sharply curtailing the ability of transgender youth to necessary medical support across the country.
Adult Treatment Also Targeted
Adult healthcare has also come under fire. The administration recently stated it would end provision of transition-related care to trans people in prisons. Incarcerated trans people will not have access to clothing or toiletries that match their identity; anyone on hormones will be forced to taper off. The new directive claims gender identity is “disconnected from biological reality” and “offers no valid reason for identification”.
Wider Consequences for Medicine
Experts have also said that restricting treatment based on flawed biology could set a path for restricting other types of treatment, like abortion and vaccines.
“This isn't only about attacking trans people, it’s attacking women’s rights, bodily autonomy around abortion, disabled people, autistic people,” McCreight said. “It’s a larger movement to try to make people conform to a specific ideal, but that ideal really comes from a particular ideology, not evidence-based fact.”
The HHS order referred to supportive treatments as “sex-rejecting procedures”, terminology that appears to have started with a conservative religious group. This language implies “a inflexible set of traits that are permanent,” the scientist said, “but that is incorrect.”
Complicated Biology of Biological Sex
Global organizations caution about confusing gender with biology, which is usually defined by “bodily characteristics” like genetic markers, gene expression, hormones, and anatomy.
The administration has had several stumbles in its effort to establish a biological definition to restrict care.
An presidential directive aimed at “gender ideology extremism” and claimed that sex is “unchangeable”, with men and women determined by sperm and egg present “at conception”.
This assertion are flawed in several ways. When ova are first conceived, they are single-celled – meaning they cannot have separate sex cells. The structures that later become eggs begin to form months later in gestation. Sperm cells only develop during puberty.
The directive did not mention intersex people, who have differences in genetics and anatomy.
What is 'Sex'?
“One of the core issues is: what exactly are we even talking about with ‘sex’? Is it about genetics? Because that doesn’t often match,” the professor said. “The majority of individuals actually have little knowledge what their XX or XY status are.”
While most people with XX chromosomes are female and XY chromosomes are men, there are also exceptions like XX males, women with XY chromosomes, and different combinations like XXY. “Science never really operates in clear-cut pairs,” an expert said. “People have far greater diversity than you would anticipate.”
Chromosomes give the body directions for development, McLaughlin said, adding: “Similar to handing actors a script is the starting point, what you actually see can be very different... because there are many additional processes that control and translate that DNA code.”
Practical Consequences and Misinformation
During the HHS announcement, a senior official spoke about young transgender people getting expensive surgeries. However, research could not find a single example of a patient under 18 receiving that operation. It was also found that the overwhelming number of breast surgeries happen among non-transgender adolescents. For the transgender youth who require operations, it is shown to be lifesaving. Denying this care “could lead to trans kids... at worst, possibly dying,” McCreight said.
Doctors and nurses may also believe misinformation about sex and gender, creating additional hurdles for trans health. “You can get care that is not as effective or even damaging,” McLaughlin said.
Trans people have long faced difficulties accessing appropriate healthcare. “There are stories about medical bias, where you go in for something obvious like a broken arm, and people will immediately try, ‘Well, maybe it’s because you’re trans,’” McLaughlin said.
Broad Societal Impact
Inaccurate beliefs about science affect everyone, not just the transgender community. Non-transgender men in the VA healthcare have had trouble getting treatment for a serious illness because of the new HHS rules.
The federal leadership is also considering further limits on abortion medications. “All individuals should be afraid – what does this mean for their medical treatment when you have officials who misunderstand science that are making rules about these issues?” McCreight said.
“They are dismantling evidence-based study as a entire field,” they added. “It’s all about discrediting knowledge. If you can’t get reliable facts, they can basically put whatever propaganda they want out there.”